I was playing around yesterday with creating what looks like spalling in concrete. I’ve titled this "Take 1' since this is the first try at this and can very well use input from others to improve the process.
I used Styrene since I had some on hand. Cardstock might be used - in fact it would be easier to work with the only caveat being that you would have to take into account that water based coloring might warp the cardstock.

I just whittled out a hole in one piece of plastic.

Well, that's what I did. As you can see in this photo that I tapered the edges of the spalled hole. I then placed this piece of styrene over the other piece and dabbed some Modge Podge in the opening. (I used Modge Podge since I had some handy.)

You can get this at your hardware store such as Lowes for example. It is intended to be mixed with a binder for grouting tile. It works great for a variety of scale sized aggregate material. I simply set the top piece of styrene to one side and sprinkled the grout on the wet Modge Podge. (I washed the Modge Podge off of the top piece of Styrene. A good reason to use for an adhesive since it is water soluble.)


I used some thin CAA and applied just enough to soak into the spalling to seal it. Next I sprayed a coat of Rust-Oleum Sandstone Fine Textured Paint. This has just enough texture to look like concrete in O scale. Note that I knocked off the excess grout prior to soaking in CAA.

I glued the two pieces of styrene together and then gave an additional overspray of the Sandstone to everything. I only wanted the color on the spalling, not so much of the texture. I then used a little A/I wash to highlight the spalling.

I was experimenting with using RIT dye as a stain for scenery (don't get on your ties/track as salt in it will rust metal parts) and had a TAN wash made up. I dribbled that here and there on the surface, letting it puddle and dry. This left some nice brownish stains on the 'concrete'. I then came back with some A/I to highlight bits and pieces.

So, there you have it. Spalled concrete - "Take 1"
Comments
I'm going to try this using cardstock. Seems to me that you could get multiple layers of spalling. I also want to see if I can get some re-bar in the thing too.
Shawn Branstetter
shortlinemodelers.com
Good idea. What if you did this .. pour a layer of plaster. Spall the areas you wish .. let dry and then cover with a layer of rubber cement .. stick something in it so you have a 'pull tab'. Pour second layer .. and when it sets up enough not to run .. but still not hard, pull the bits of rubber cement up. Might work.
Dang. I'm out of plaster! :)
Shawn Branstetter
shortlinemodelers.com
Oh. About re-bar .. thinking that 1/2" re-bar is about 0.11" in O scale and 0.006" in HO. I have some small dia solder that is 0.022" .. 1' in O scale. A little too thick .. BUT .. re-bar has those ridges you know? I took a piece of this solder and rolled it back and forth a file at 90° to the serrations. Some rust paint ..
Shawn Branstetter
shortlinemodelers.com
ed has done again
Shawn Branstetter
shortlinemodelers.com
Yeah .. I had seen that. That is SOME heavily damaged concrete! I was thinking about showing a little rebar .. might be cool to embed into the 'concrete'
Shawn Branstetter
shortlinemodelers.com
Try this. Cast a bit of wall with embedded "re-bar". Put something like N-scale ballast in places and pour plaster. When it sets up you should be able to knock the ballast loose .. exposing the 're-bar'. Might be fun to play with.