Further Explorations in Making Foam Rocks

By David Eblen, photos by the author.

I was so intrigued with Ed Traxler’s foam rock construction article I began to hack and slash away at foam blocks looking for something that might fit in with my Arizona based railroad setting. First effort produced spectacular soaring cliffs that will be installed in an appropriate spot at a later date. I was amazed at how easy it was to obtain really nice results and named the cliffs “Traxler Bluffs” in honor of Ed’s technique. Still, I needed other rocks that weren’t quite so ragged and sharp edged. Older, smoother specimens exposed to water and wind erosion.

In a sort of coalescing of “hints and tips”, the “Ties that bind” article I wrote recently featured a stretch of track that immediately found a spot on the layout isolated by a baranca or desert gulch. I have natural rocks that fill the bill, mostly, but needed a few more to pile into the creek and on the surrounding banks. I wondered if a smoother rock from foam was possible and if it was practical to match the coloration of the “real” rock already in place.

I started by using 60 grit sandpaper on a small block of blue foam and sanded/carved a sort of rock like shape into it. Didn’t look like a rock. I threw it into the trash box under the layout.  But I had another idea and grabbed another block of foam.  I chipped away at it with my thumb nail much like Ed suggested in the first place. When I had it all shaped the way I liked, THEN I took the 60 grit paper to it. It worked!!  When it was rough shaped to my liking I grabbed some 220 grit sandpaper and smoothed things out making sure I had taken all the really sharp edges off and smoothed out the ragged surfaces left where the foam had broken when I snapped off the pieces with my fingernails.

Lastly, I used acrylic paints to color the foam. Use a real rock or photos to determine the proper colors. I also used powdered chalks to add color and texture. There is no reason to repeat those techniques here; they are all over the internet and other model building media.

The three basic stages of rock “construction”. From left to right, finger nail chipping, sanding and painting/texturing.

I had one rock I needed to custom fit in a specific location.  In this case I had to laminate two sheets of foam together to get the proper thickness.  I used hot glue (cool). If this is required, when you get the rock fully shaped and sanded, you’ll need to fill it all around the seam with putty of some sort. I use dry wall compound (all purpose) but plaster of Paris will work as well as hydrocal.  Maybe a paper based material like Sculptamold would also work. The plaster based products absorb the paint about like the foam does and so doesn’t cause a distracting mark if the paint wouldn’t absorb. In the picture you are staring directly at the glue line. It runs vertically through the model but is impossible to see

This custom fit rock is 2” thick (or wide). It was laminated from 2 pieces of blue foam and finished with acrylic paint and texture paint techniques using chalk dust.

Try this, you may never again spend time hunched over, scouring a desert for rocks to fit that perfect spot on your layout, only to look up clutching your bag of boulders, to answer the 5 year old who appeared out of nowhere, “Whatch yer doin’ mister?

The new foam rocks in their places.  This is the extreme railroad East end of the Tonopah Southern.  It is the first place to be sceniced and is the default experimental scenery area on my layout.  It is, of course, unfinished but beginning to come together.  The "rocks" fell right into their slots and it is now difficult to tell them from the "real" ones. 

Warning

Sanding blue foam creates very fine particles that cling to everything including your lungs. Wear protective breathing devices. It also sticks to your clothes, fingers, shoes, hair, arm pits and anything else it can get to. Work over an empty box or trash container and use a vacuum cleaner to remove residue from your local work area as well as yourself. It may prevent a domestic disturbance.

About the Author

David Eblen's picture
What I am is a retired 38 year veteran Locomotive Engineer for the Southern Pacific Railroad. I have been building models since I was 7 years old. Airplanes, boats, cars but mostly trains. That would make 58 years worth. I also build full sized boats and the modeling helps that endeavor because of the focus on detail required.

Comments

David Eblen's picture

Addendum: It is probably obvious but the foam can also be glued with adhesives besides hot glue. Including but not limited to White and Yellow glue, epoxy and foam safe CA's and polyurethanes. The hot glue is virtually instantaneous, however, and I find it convenient. (My wife uses it for her craft projects and she always keeps a supply of the cool sticks on hand)

eTraxx's picture

David, excellent. Using foam to make rocks is not only easy but fun too. Like you said .. you can make them 'custom fit' as you need. If you are using something other then the DOW blue foam be prepared for different results. I have some light green foam I got on the last trip to Lowes that is different then the blue stuff. The 'green stuff' acts more like compressed fiber then the blue foam .. has more of a layered structure. Shrug. I just used a wire brush and made it .. layered. :) .. then .. I got more green foam that is very much like a florist's foam. I haven't even explored the pink foam yet!

Like you I found that hot glue worked pretty well. You need to try and get the low-temp glue though (think this is the 'cool' sticks you mention). The problem I have found with white/yellow glue is that these glues set up by contact with air. Often if you glue two pieces of foam together the glue takes a long time to set .. suppose it's lack of air getting to it. I have had some success with using the cement sold at Lowes specifically for use with foam .. but like the hot-glue method best.

David Eblen's picture

I suffer from age related brain freezes. The "cool" I mentioned was indeed "low temp" hot glue. Seems like oxymorons no matter how you say them. The world is full of "foams" of different types and I have to admit that the blue type is all that I have tried. Every store I go into seems to stock a different "color" and they are Different. Some closed cell, some open, different weight per cubic inch, different base materials. Styrene, polyurethane etc. I'll keep hacking away at it. I'm sure there are advantages to some or all of them for different rock types, or maybe not!!

eTraxx's picture

Yeah. The 'Blue Stuff' that works so well is a DOW product. They say that it is "Manufactured through a continuous extrusion process, with a rigid closed cell structure. The 'Green Stuff' I got at Lowes is called Green Guard. It also says it's a rigid closed cell structure .. but diff that I see is that it contains up to 30% recycled material (hence the'Green')

The *other* Green Stuff (let's call it GS2) is the one that looks and feels like green styrofoam/florist's foam. The stuff I have is about 2" thick. It ALSO is called Green Guard. Sheesh. This stuff is more like regular Styrofoam to me. So far I like the Blue Stuff best. That first Green Guard to me ... is more like working with a compressed paper. It has a grain and tears instead of fracturing like the Blue Stuff.

That SECOND Green Guard .. the one seemingly more like Styrofoam appears to fracture similar to the Blue Stuff. Think the point (if there is one) is that depending on what foam you get (and I am sitting here LOOKING at two different foams with the same name. Go figure.) .. you have to adapt the rock-making to that foam. No biggie. I fractured the Blue Stuff .. and that first Green Stuff .. since it wanted to tear .. I just used a knife and wire brush to make layered rock. Worked good for both.

In this pic .. the 'knotted up' rock on the lower bit is from the Blue Stuff. The layered rock on top is made from the Green Stuff.

 

Subscribe to the Shortline Modelers Lounge newsletter to get the latest news and information delivered in your inbox.